Most business owners think a review fades over time. The truth is, employee reviews on sites like Glassdoor or Indeed can stick around for years. They show up in search results, shape hiring decisions, and affect customer trust. The question is, can old employee reviews hurt your reputation years later? The answer is yes, and the impact can be bigger than you expect.
Why Employee Reviews Carry Weight
Job seekers trust employee reviews. A 2023 Glassdoor survey found that 86 percent of employees and job seekers read reviews before applying for a job. That means one bitter comment from 2017 can still be shaping how people see your business in 2025.
For customers, these reviews also matter. Many people search a company before buying. If they see stories about toxic culture, poor management, or high turnover, they may doubt the quality of your service.
One small marketing firm in Boston shared that a single Glassdoor review from 2019 claiming “unrealistic hours and no work-life balance” kept appearing on page one of search results. Even though the leadership team had changed, new applicants brought it up in every interview.
How Old Reviews Stay Alive
Search Engines Favor High-Authority Sites
Sites like Glassdoor, Indeed, and Comparably have strong rankings. That means their pages often appear above your company’s own site.
AI and Recommendation Engines
Even without AI summaries, search algorithms pull reviews into knowledge panels and highlight snippets. Old negatives may be what shows up first.
Lack of New Content
If you do not encourage recent employees to leave reviews, the old ones stay at the top by default.
The Real Risks of Old Reviews
Hiring Challenges
Talented candidates may skip applying if reviews make your company sound unstable. A recruiter in Austin admitted, “We had to explain every interview that our Glassdoor reviews were outdated. We lost strong candidates who never even gave us a chance.”
Customer Trust
Clients often Google a business before signing contracts. If employee reviews suggest a toxic workplace, customers question professionalism.
Long-Term Reputation Damage
Unlike customer reviews that may get buried, employee reviews sit in one place for years. Without action, they define your reputation long after the facts have changed.
How to Push Back Against Old Reviews
Ask for Fresh Feedback
Encourage current employees to share honest reviews. Do not pressure them to write only positive ones. A mix of recent, balanced reviews helps bury old negatives and shows growth.
Respond to Reviews Publicly
On Glassdoor and similar sites, companies can reply. Even to old reviews, a thoughtful response matters. A simple reply like, “This was from 2019, and since then we have new leadership and flexible schedules” helps put the comment in context.
Highlight Employee Stories on Your Site
Post employee spotlights, testimonials, or case studies. This adds fresh content to search results that compete with older reviews.
Improve Internally
Sometimes old reviews reflect real issues. If employees complained about pay, benefits, or management style, show how you fixed it. Candidates notice when changes match past complaints.
Why Ignoring Old Reviews Is Risky
It is tempting to shrug off old complaints. But search results live forever. If you do not address them, they become the story.
A startup in San Diego ignored a string of bad Glassdoor reviews from their early days. Years later, they had doubled in size and improved culture, but when a potential investor Googled them, those reviews appeared first. The deal fell apart.
Old reviews are not just employee chatter. They can block hiring, sales, and growth opportunities.
How to Monitor Employee Reviews
Check Monthly
Make it a habit to check Glassdoor, Indeed, and similar sites each month. Track what is new and what is still showing up in search.
Use Alerts
Set Google Alerts for your company name plus keywords like “review” or “Glassdoor.” This gives you early warning when reviews get picked up by other sites.
Benchmark Competitors
See how your reviews compare to others in your industry. If competitors have fresher or better reviews, they may attract talent and clients first.
Tools and Services That Can Help
Managing reputation across employee review sites can be overwhelming. Here are three services that can support you:
- Erase: Focuses on removing or suppressing harmful search results, including outdated reviews that dominate page one.
- Reputation Recharge: Specializes in building fresh, positive content that pushes down old negatives in search rankings.
- Brand24: Tracks online mentions across review sites, forums, and blogs, so you can see where your company name is being discussed.
These tools give you cleanup, promotion, and monitoring power.
Practical Steps Right Now
- Search Your Company: Type your name into Google. Look at what employee reviews appear on the first two pages.
- Respond Where Possible: Reply to outdated reviews with updates about what has changed.
- Ask Current Employees: Encourage them to leave balanced reviews on Glassdoor or Indeed.
- Share New Stories: Publish content highlighting team growth, culture changes, or benefits updates.
- Track Progress: Revisit search results every month to see what shifts.
- Seek Help if Needed: If harmful old reviews dominate, use services like Erase or Reputation Recharge to suppress them.
The Bigger Picture
Employee reviews are not just for job seekers. They shape public trust, client decisions, and even investment deals. Old reviews may no longer reflect who you are, but they still show up and influence how people see you.
The goal is not to remove negative reviews but to update the narrative. Show progress. Provide context. Highlight the present, not the past.
Final Thoughts
So, can old employee reviews hurt your reputation years later? Absolutely. They linger in search results and influence decisions long after the facts have changed.
The solution is not to hide from them, but to act. Ask for new reviews, reply to old ones, create positive content, and monitor your results. With steady action and the help of tools like Erase, Reputation Recharge, and Brand24, you can shift the balance.
Your online reputation is not defined by the past. It is shaped by what you do today to control the story.
Leave a Reply